Sacred Land News

September 7, 2004
Woodruff Butte Lawsuit Affirms Sacred Site Protections
Posted by: Toby McLeod

Opponents of sacred site protection have failed again. In our film, In the Light of Reverence, we told the story of an Arizona butte that is sacred to the Hopi and Zuni where mining for gravel has destroyed nine Hopi shrines. The owner of Woodruff Butte teamed up with Mountain States Legal Foundation to argue that Arizona’s Department of Transportation policy banning the use of material mined from the sacred butte in state construction projects represented an endorsement of native religion in violation of the First Amendment establishment clause. On September 1, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that rather than advancing any particular religion, safeguarding Native American sacred sites “has historical value for the nation as a whole.” Judge Betty B. Fletcher wrote: “Native American sacred sites of historical value are entitled to the same protection as the many Judeo-Christian religious sites.” Read the decision here.

Leave a Reply

Comment display may be delayed for moderation.

 
Search
Recent Comments
  • Marlo McKenzie: Thank you for your comment Stephen, that means a lot to us!
  • Stephen Ruppenthal: Inspiring and touching work, Toby. This three-minute short is very well articulate and has a lot...
  • Hoagy: This article on First Majestic and the Wirakuta might be of interest - http://lapoliticaeslapoliti...
  • Karl E. Rohrbaugh: I have been to both Paha Sapa and Paha Mota. I have looked accross the prarie from the summit of...
  • Ashton Cooper: This is our life, our culture, our traditions at stake here. Haven’t we (as Aboriginal People)...
Stay Connected,
Join the Sacred Land Defense Team!
Sign up to receive action alerts, reports from the field and newsletters. Protecting sacred places is our mission - we can't do it alone!
Post Archives
SLFP on Twitter